Let Me Tell You About My Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Habit…
So, picture this: It’s Wednesday, raining buckets outside, and I’m standing in the kitchen, hungry (or maybe just bored—hard to tell sometimes). I open the fridge and you know what stares back? Cheese. Bread. Butter. That’s it. Classic, right? And then I remember the air fryer I got last Christmas which I swore I’d use every day for healthy stuff but… well, grilled cheese counts as healthy if you squint, yeah?! Anyway, that’s how my air fryer grilled cheese ritual started. I’ve made this so many times now that, honestly, my kids roll their eyes and say, “Again?” but they always eat it. Besides, the air fryer makes it so crispy I’ve basically retired my old frying pan. Good riddance.
Why I Keep Making This Even When I Swore I’d Eat More Salad
I make this when I can’t really be bothered to cook but still want something warm and melty (and, let’s be real, comforting). My family goes crazy for this because the bread gets that perfect crunch—no more soggy bottoms. I used to hate how grilled cheese in a skillet sometimes burns in one spot and stays pale in another, but the air fryer is weirdly consistent, like a robot that only knows how to do grilled cheese (I wish it could do my taxes too).
(Oh, and when I’m exhausted or the kids are hangry, this is just so much faster than babysitting a pan.)
Here’s What You’ll Need (Substitutions Welcome!)
- 2 slices bread (white, wheat, sourdough, whatever’s languishing in your pantry really—I’ve even used ends and it’s fine)
- 1-2 slices cheese (I usually default to sharp cheddar, but American is classic, or even mozzarella if you’re into stretchy cheese pulls. Swiss is great, but my son calls it “hole cheese” and refuses to eat it, so use at your own risk.)
- Butter, about a tablespoon (margarine works if you’re out of butter; my grandmother always insisted on Kerrygold, but honestly any butter spreads fine)
- Optional: a sprinkle of garlic powder, or some thin tomato slices if you’re feeling zippy
How I Usually Throw This Together
- Slap some butter on one side of each slice of bread. Be generous, but not so much that your bread gets soggy. Actually, if you accidentally go a bit overboard, it’ll just be extra golden.
- Stack your cheese between the unbuttered sides of the bread. (This is where I occasionally sneak a little extra cheese in. No shame.)
- Place the sandwich in the air fryer basket, buttered side out, obviously. If your air fryer’s tiny, smush the sandwich a bit—it rebounds.
- Set the air fryer to 180°C (about 360°F). Let it cook for 6–8 minutes, flipping halfway if you want both sides to be equally crispy. (To be honest, I sometimes forget to flip and it’s still good. Don’t stress.)
- If at any point your cheese isn’t as melty as you want, give it another minute. But watch it! I’ve burnt a few in my day because I got distracted by the dog barking at the mailman.
- When it’s golden and smells basically irresistible, take it out and let it cool for, I dunno, a minute? Or as long as you can resist. (I never last; my tongue is a burnt sacrifice every single time.)
What I’ve Learned (Sometimes the Hard Way)
- If you overload the cheese, it might ooze out the sides; that’s not a bad thing in my book, but it’s a messier cleanup.
- Sometimes the bread flies around in the air fryer—if that happens, just pin it down with a little rack or a toothpick poked through the sandwich (don’t forget to remove it afterwards! Learned that the hard way.)
- I used to think you needed fancy bakery bread, but, honestly, supermarket stuff is perfectly fine for this.
Experiments That (Mostly) Worked—And One That Didn’t
- Once I spread a tiny bit of Dijon mustard inside—wow. Not for everyone, but I loved it.
- I’ve tried adding thin apple slices for crunch—good, but only if you’re into sweet-savoury clashes.
- One time I tried sprinkling cinnamon sugar on the buttered side (don’t ask, I was distracted)—big nope. Kids still remind me about the “weird toast incident”.
- If you want to go wild, check out Serious Eats’ grilled cheese experiments—they’ve tried everything.
Do I Really Need an Air Fryer? (Sort of…)
Look, if you don’t have an air fryer (yet!), you can honestly just make this under the broiler or even in a toaster oven. Or a pan, old-school style. I sometimes use my oven’s convection setting when my air fryer’s full of something else (like frozen fries). But the air fryer does make it faster and ridiculously easy to clean up. If you’re thinking of getting one—here’s a resource I found super helpful: NYT Wirecutter’s air fryer picks.
How Long Does It Keep? (Not That I’d Know)
Alright, technically you can store leftover grilled cheese in the fridge for a day or two and reheat it in the air fryer. But, in my house, it never actually lasts more than a day—someone always grabs it for a midnight snack. If you do stash it away, just reheat at 160°C (320°F) for about 2–3 minutes. It crisps up again, almost as good as fresh. I think it tastes better the next day, but apparently I’m in the minority here.
How We Eat This (You Can Judge)
At our place, we always serve it with tomato soup (from a can; I said this was lazy day food). Or sometimes, I just dunk it in ketchup. My brother-in-law swears by hot sauce, so knock yourself out. Once, my daughter insisted we cut the sandwiches into dinosaur shapes—messy but adorable.
Pro Tips I Learned The Hard Way
- I once tried to rush the preheating and ended up with uneven crispy bits. Actually, I find it works better if you let the air fryer preheat for 3 minutes first.
- If you use super-thick bread, you may need to cook a minute or two longer; otherwise, the cheese inside just sits there like a lump.
- Don’t stack sandwiches in the basket—trust me, they need their space or they get all squished.
Questions People Keep Asking Me (No, Really, I’ve Been Texted These At Midnight)
- Can I use vegan cheese?
- Yep, totally! Just be aware some brands melt better than others. Violife melts pretty well, in my experience.
- Is it possible to make more than one sandwich at a time?
- Kind of! Depends on the size of your air fryer. I cram in two, but they might come out a bit squished. Still tasty.
- Do I need to flip it?
- Honestly, sometimes I forget and it’s fine, but flipping halfway gives the best crunch on both sides.
- Why is my bread flying around?
- This happens with really light bread or if you use a big air fryer. Just stick a small rack or weight on top.
- Can I freeze these?
- You can, but I wouldn’t. The bread goes weird when you reheat. Just make it fresh, it’s so quick anyway.
So that’s my not-so-secret, slightly rambling air fryer grilled cheese process. If you try something wild, let me know how it turns out—unless it’s cinnamon sugar, then maybe keep that one to yourself.
Ingredients
- 4 slices of white bread
- 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
- 2 slices cheddar cheese
- 2 slices mozzarella cheese
- 1 tablespoon mayonnaise (optional)
- 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder (optional)
- 1/4 teaspoon dried parsley (optional)
- Pinch of salt
Instructions
-
1Preheat the air fryer to 370°F (188°C) for 2 minutes.
-
2Spread softened butter evenly on one side of each bread slice. Optionally, mix mayonnaise with garlic powder and parsley, and spread on the inside of the bread.
-
3Place a slice of cheddar and a slice of mozzarella cheese between two slices of bread, with the buttered sides facing out.
-
4Arrange the sandwiches in the air fryer basket in a single layer. Cook for 4 minutes, then carefully flip and cook for another 3-4 minutes until golden brown and crispy.
-
5Remove from the air fryer, let cool slightly, slice, and serve warm.
Approximate Information for One Serving
Nutrition Disclaimers
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you make this recipe?
Please consider Pinning it!!
